Lista laureatów Nagroda Mythopoeic dla literatury fantasy (1971–1991) Rok Tytuł Autor 1971 The Crystal Cave Mary Stewart 1972 Red Moon and Black Mountain 1973 The Song of Rhiannon 1974 The Hollow Hills Mary Stewart 1975 A Midsummer Tempest Poul Anderson 1981 Niedokończone opowieści (Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-earth) J.R.R. Tolkien 1982 Małe, duże (Little, Big) John Crowley 1983 The Firelings 1984 When Voiha Wakes 1985 Cards of Grief Jane Yolen 1986 Bridge of Birds 1987 The Folk of the Air Peter Beagle 1988 Siódmy syn (The Seventh Son) Orson Scott Card 1989 Unicorn Mountain Michael Bishop 1990 The Stress of Her Regard Tim Powers 1991 Thomas the Rhymer Ellen Kushner
Nagroda Mythopoeic dla literatury fantasy w kategorii literatura dla dorosłych (od 1992) Rok Tytuł Autor 1992 A Woman of the Iron People 1993 Briar Rose Jane Yolen 1994 The Porcelain Dove Delia Sherman 1995 Something Rich and Strange Patricia A. McKillip 1996 (Waking the Moon) Elizabeth Hand 1997 The Wood Wife Terri Windling 1998 The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye A.S. Byatt 1999 Gwiezdny pył (Stardust) Neil Gaiman i 2000 Tamsin Peter S. Beagle 2001 The Innamorati 2002 Klątwa nad Chalionem (The Curse of Chalion) Lois McMaster Bujold 2003 Ombria in Shadow Patricia A.