Louis St. Laurent (1952–1957) John Diefenbaker (1957–1963) Lester Pearson (1963–1968) Pierre Trudeau (1968–1979, 1980–1984) Joe Clark (1979–1980) John Turner (1984) Brian Mulroney (1984–1993) Kim Campbell (1993) Jean Chrétien (1993–2003) Paul Martin (2003–2006) Stephen Harper (2006–2015) Justin Trudeau (od 2015)
Eric Gairy (1974–1979) Maurice Bishop (de facto 1979–1983) Herbert Blaize (1984–1989) Ben Jones (1989–1990) Nicholas Brathwaite (1990–1995) George Brizan (1995) Keith Mitchell (1995–2008, od 2013) Tillman Thomas (2008–2013)
Norman Manley (1959–1962) Alexander Bustamante (1962–1967) Donald Sangster (1967) Hugh Shearer (1967–1972) Michael Manley (1972–1980, 1989–1992) Edward Seaga (1980–1989) Percival Patterson (1992–2006) Portia Simpson-Miller (2006–2007, 2012–2016) Bruce Golding (2007–2011) Andrew Holness (2011–2012, od 2016)
Sidney Holland (1952–1957) Keith Holyoake (1957, 1960–1972) Walter Nash (1957–1960) Jack Marshall (1972) Norman Kirk (1972–1974) Bill Rowling (1974–1975) Robert Muldoon (1975–1984) David Lange (1984–1989) Geoffrey Palmer (1989–1990) Mike Moore (1990) Jim Bolger (1990–1997) Jenny Shipley (1997–1999) Helen Clark (1999–2008) John Key (2008–2016) Bill English (2016–2017) Jacinda Ardern (od 2017)